Writings of one autistic woman. Poems, stories, opinions, memoir and photos.
Thursday, 6 July 2017
Consequential Loss - Notes On A Radio Play And Autistic Theatre
I recently took the plunge and joined up with a theatre group for autistic people. It's a pretty new group and the people there are varied. There autism is as varied as they are. What everyone shares is enthusiasm.
The core group meet currently for one day a week, being joined for the morning by a group from a local college of ESPA (Education and Services for People with Autism). We have fun and are supported in what we do by two paid staff members who work more or less full time for the Twisting Ducks Theatre Company which is run for people with learning difficulties and (now) autism.
I feel very fortunate to be able to go and have fun with the people of Spectrum Theatre - the autistic child of the Twisting Ducks. It is hoped that in the future some extra funding can be obtained which would mean that the work of Spectrum could develop a lot further. Also in the near future there's going to be an eight week creative writing course - which we're really meant to call creative storytelling in recognition that there may be people on that course who have amazing imaginations but who can't write or can't write well enough to set down their fantastic stories on paper.
I'm also very fortunate in that the current funding obtained for Spectrum means that the day that's laid on for we autistic people is free of charge.
I've met some great people in Spectrum, all autistic and all experiencing joys and trials that accompany our condition. And it's just one more way for me to open up to my own creative possibilities and the possibilities of others. For now it is a place I will stay. I make no predictions for the future.
Almost the first thing the core group were asked to do was to write a radio play. Each of us would write, with the idea being that we will record the plays and put them out on a local community radio station.
I've written quite a lot in the past year, though not as much I would have liked. But I've never attempted a play either from scratch or from adapting one of my crazy stories.
I have now written a play. And then it had to be edited - the censor's pen had to be used. The broadcasts would be daytime and I accidentally wrote something with adult content and language including rather more swearing than families would appreciate. I'd written a late night show or something to adapt into a theatre piece with a 15+ age warning.
I've been my own censor though. The fruity language has been removed or toned down and I wonder in places whether I've lost realism. I've adjusted quite a few lines. Watered down sex references and some imagery that the BBC controller would have banned. I'm glad the actual plot is unchanged. There's still the darkness and light, the despair, the betrayals, the hope. I'm glad I haven't been asked to make the plot insipid
There's also the matter of religion. One of the characters is a religious homophobic bigot. I can write religious bigots. I know the subject first hand! The character is quite extreme but I've known people who are equally extreme and equally nasty about it too. I thankful I didn't get quite that bad myself in my own years of religious homophobia. I think that the character worked as I wrote her. She's still there too. She's surviving the censor. But her language and bile is a little mellowed. I also considered the intended audience and wondered whether they would be up in arms about my attack on the Christian faith. It's not really that of course, just an attack on a particular manifestation of the faith, the version that names people like me as abominations. For a late night broadcast or a theatre I'd let it stand. But not for this intended broadcast. So I've taken pains to point out that not all Christians are like that.
Since the broadcast will be in Newcastle I've pointed to a few of the churches here in which being queer won't result in the preacher abusing you or consigning you to hell for your sexuality and gender. Who knows? Perhaps someone will hear it who is a Christian and is queer too but hiding the truth and fighting against themselves through guilt. Just as I did. Perhaps someone like that will hear and something will be planted in them that helps them seek out a place where they can live their faith in more freedom. I can live in the hope that a radio play might do some good.
I've deliberately kept the scenes simple. Deliberately linked them with narration from the main character. I think, as a first attempt at writing a play, it has worked out well. Unfortunately I now want to re-edit it to put some of the fruitier language and imagery back in and have two versions of it to play with.
Each of us in that core group has written a play. They are as varied as we are. I've ended up being the only one of us to include nothing from the realms of science fiction and fantasy. Much as I love those genres - and need to get back to working on my post-apocalyptic dystopian novel - I've ended up firmly rooted in the real world. The other plays are each filled with their own surprises and it's a good thing that they are such contrasts from each other.
My first scene was initially written at a Spectrum session. We were all told to write a scene. One simple idea popped into my head and it just flowed with hardly another conscious thought. Two friends meet in a cafe. One confesses to the other that she is having an affair. She was having it with a man named Graham. But as I wrote his name my pen paused, almost the only break it gave to my writing hand. My pen considered its options. Crossed out the word Graham. And wrote the word Erica.
Since that day I haven't made any enormous changes to the scene - just a few, arising from details the characters gave me about themselves as they wrote the rest of the play for me. It's always nice when people can hardly believe that I've just written something from scratch in a writing session. That happens sometimes. Other times I can hardly write anything at all and any words that get miserably scrawled should really only be filed in the embarrassing section.
I hope that writing the play has taught me something about the process. Something I can put to good use later. I hope too that it will give me a little more confidence in writing conversations. I never used to include much in the way of conversation because I didn't think I understood the rules of conversation well enough to write one. I hope that this play is a step on the path to being able to write realistic and engaging talk. I don't think I'm there yet.
Sometime soon I'll probably post the whole play here. Unless I go crazy, edit it more and try and get someone more professional to record it. That's always a possibility.
So, onwards with Spectrum. See where it leads. I'm guessing it may throw me in a few surprising directions. And I'm happy with that idea.
Friday, 16 June 2017
The Lament of Asherah, Creation Goddess, Bride of Yahweh
A lament from Asherah, bride of Yahweh. Free-written in a writing group in a Newcastle cafe on June 13th. Do any of you wish to follow her call?
![]() | |
Image saved from https://uk.pinterest.com/pin/381046818447394805/ |
I am the forgotten one.
I am the one who walks in the fields;
Leaving behind her the trails of trees,
Creating the life-springs, homes for my birds,
The smile sanctuaries of squirrels and sloths.
I am the springer of springs,
The overflow of life in a thousand rivers
And a billion glasses of iconic crystal clarity.
I am the forgotten one.
I am the obscurity who once was worshipped.
Where people sheltered under my shade protection
They now strike me down in rain-forest deaths.
I am still here: Earth protector, restorer,
The pattern for the turning of worlds.
I am the forgotten one.
I am your Asherah, the rejected goddess,
The impulse of compassion lingering in the
Religions of men. Monotonal without my feminine.
I'm Diana, Luna, I ride the fire as Hecate,
Waltz as Demeter, and I sprinkle wisdom dew
Each morning, longing to hear again the name
Of Astarte or Isis on the lips of the bold.
I am the forgotten one.
I am the one whose altars were destroyed in hate
By those who replaced my free spirit
With a god they could only present as jealous.
The religious slaughtered me through time and space
Breaking themselves apart in the killing
I wept for the sons of men but they beheld
Only a manly touch in the spreading of rainbows.
I am the forgotten one.
I wait for you, my child, my lover
To embrace my joy, cherish your footprints
And rest again under the holy greenwood tree.
Thursday, 15 June 2017
A Letter To The Telegraph About Autism and Special Interests
A letter to The Daily Telegraph. I'll explain it afterwards.
Dear Sirs,
I read with interest your article of June 12th regarding the difficulties of being autistic. I note that the article was written by someone who is not themselves autistic and am dismayed to see that his portrayal of the autistic experience was overwhelmingly negative. I am writing to you as a happy autistic woman in order to correct this portrayal by focusing on a positive aspect of being autistic.
Being autistic is a trial. No doubt about it. You wouldn't ever look at us and say, "Wow! I wish I was autistic too." Not with everything we go through. Your article was right. The autistic experience can be excruciatingly difficult.
But it can be a great joy too. People talk of autistic ecstasy and that's a thing. It's real. For me at least, and I choose to focus on the joy. When I can. Sometimes that overwhelming overloading collapse of everything within takes over.
I'm not going to list the joys and the total fun I have. I just want to tell you about one aspect of it. You see, we autistic people tend to focus in on things. When we find that particular thing our brains scream out, "Wow! Wow! This is for me!" and then we don't ever let go of it and seek to find an everlasting corridor filled with more and more and more of it. It's not an obsession. Oh no. Not quite. We call these things our special interests.
We all have them and we discuss them too. Join an autism group and inevitably the subject will arise many times because we like our special interests and there's always this part of us wondering why everyone doesn't share them with us and why they switch off when we infodump at them.
So. Imagine the online conversation. Me? I don't have to imaging. It's already happened.
New member: Just out of interest, what are everyone's special interests?
Old members: Trains. Helicopters. Tapestry. My Little Pony. Or, and these are all common, Nazis. Serial Killers. Murder. And darkest of all, weather forecasting.
They read about these things. They know everything. Collect ponies. Become meteorologists. They don't actually become serial killers of course.
Then it's my turn. They ask me, "What are your special interests?"
Me: Fraud, bigamy, and highway robbery.
You read that right. I should explain though, clarify a little. Because while fraud and bigamy are true and perfect special interests, robbery is just a hobby. It makes me happy. After a hard day, when autism has given me problems and my brain feels like it's going to implode and explode at the same time, after those days there's nothing better than popping out for a bit of highway robbery.
Being outside helps me. Under the bare black night sky when the rushing clouds call to me or the stars send messages that it's all going to be okay. I'd be out there anyway, even without the robbery.
And I say all this in the groups. Explain how I get a thrill from all the logical steps you need to successfully get away with fraud.
I talk too about how you need to be very careful when indulging in a spot of bigamy. Or biandry. Polyandry really because right now I have four husbands on the go. James is alright. But the other three are complete shits. I'm looking forward to divorcing them but it's a complicated business and I have to follow all the logical plan perfectly. I love logical plans. They make me tingle inside. It's hard to get a worthwhile divorce settlement from your rich shit of a husband when you're not legally hitched in the first place.
Sometimes the things I say produce less than positive reactions, even in an autism group. I don't know why. I mean, trains and My Little Pony? How dull can you get? But I don't moan when people are into weird things. Some of those people don't grant me the same respect when I'm sharing my happy things.
Fraud, bigamy and highway robbery.
Talk about autistic ecstasy!
Pointing a pistol at a tourist and demanding their cash and valuables. Now that's ecstasy. You wouldn't understand it. Unless you're autistic too. I would ask therefore that all future articles you publish about autism would be more positive than the one I read this week in order to reflect the deep wonder we can find in this world.
Yours Faithfully.
Ann Meders
On June 13th I attended a writers' group. The subject of the morning was female highwaymen, or highwaywomen depending on your preference.
During the course of the session an article was read about several of these women. If you care to read it you can find it here. One of the sentences reads, "Alongside highway robbery, Ann Meders born in 1643, made fraud and bigamy her special interests."
That was enough for me. Out of all these women, the bored and the desperate, out of all their deeds, I couldn't leave that sentence behind. Hence the above letter. It was actually free written in the cafe as a monologue. I've altered it a little to make it a letter, but only as far as necessary. Ann Meders was hung at the age of thirty. I think my fictional autistic Ann would get into trouble too after sending that letter.
I will stress that while I have my special interests, and while special interests do get discussed sometimes in groups, I do not share the interests of Ann Meders and I haven't seen Ann's interests raised. I've seen all the others she mentions in her letters. They're real. But I haven't seen anyone plotting how to defraud their illegal husbands. I also have no good reason to claim Ann as an autistic woman or to place a seventeenth century highway robber in the position of being able to join online autism groups.
![]() |
Image taken from the page mentioned below |
Dear Sirs,
I read with interest your article of June 12th regarding the difficulties of being autistic. I note that the article was written by someone who is not themselves autistic and am dismayed to see that his portrayal of the autistic experience was overwhelmingly negative. I am writing to you as a happy autistic woman in order to correct this portrayal by focusing on a positive aspect of being autistic.
Being autistic is a trial. No doubt about it. You wouldn't ever look at us and say, "Wow! I wish I was autistic too." Not with everything we go through. Your article was right. The autistic experience can be excruciatingly difficult.
But it can be a great joy too. People talk of autistic ecstasy and that's a thing. It's real. For me at least, and I choose to focus on the joy. When I can. Sometimes that overwhelming overloading collapse of everything within takes over.
I'm not going to list the joys and the total fun I have. I just want to tell you about one aspect of it. You see, we autistic people tend to focus in on things. When we find that particular thing our brains scream out, "Wow! Wow! This is for me!" and then we don't ever let go of it and seek to find an everlasting corridor filled with more and more and more of it. It's not an obsession. Oh no. Not quite. We call these things our special interests.
We all have them and we discuss them too. Join an autism group and inevitably the subject will arise many times because we like our special interests and there's always this part of us wondering why everyone doesn't share them with us and why they switch off when we infodump at them.
So. Imagine the online conversation. Me? I don't have to imaging. It's already happened.
New member: Just out of interest, what are everyone's special interests?
Old members: Trains. Helicopters. Tapestry. My Little Pony. Or, and these are all common, Nazis. Serial Killers. Murder. And darkest of all, weather forecasting.
They read about these things. They know everything. Collect ponies. Become meteorologists. They don't actually become serial killers of course.
Then it's my turn. They ask me, "What are your special interests?"
Me: Fraud, bigamy, and highway robbery.
You read that right. I should explain though, clarify a little. Because while fraud and bigamy are true and perfect special interests, robbery is just a hobby. It makes me happy. After a hard day, when autism has given me problems and my brain feels like it's going to implode and explode at the same time, after those days there's nothing better than popping out for a bit of highway robbery.
Being outside helps me. Under the bare black night sky when the rushing clouds call to me or the stars send messages that it's all going to be okay. I'd be out there anyway, even without the robbery.
And I say all this in the groups. Explain how I get a thrill from all the logical steps you need to successfully get away with fraud.
I talk too about how you need to be very careful when indulging in a spot of bigamy. Or biandry. Polyandry really because right now I have four husbands on the go. James is alright. But the other three are complete shits. I'm looking forward to divorcing them but it's a complicated business and I have to follow all the logical plan perfectly. I love logical plans. They make me tingle inside. It's hard to get a worthwhile divorce settlement from your rich shit of a husband when you're not legally hitched in the first place.
Sometimes the things I say produce less than positive reactions, even in an autism group. I don't know why. I mean, trains and My Little Pony? How dull can you get? But I don't moan when people are into weird things. Some of those people don't grant me the same respect when I'm sharing my happy things.
Fraud, bigamy and highway robbery.
Talk about autistic ecstasy!
Pointing a pistol at a tourist and demanding their cash and valuables. Now that's ecstasy. You wouldn't understand it. Unless you're autistic too. I would ask therefore that all future articles you publish about autism would be more positive than the one I read this week in order to reflect the deep wonder we can find in this world.
Yours Faithfully.
Ann Meders
On June 13th I attended a writers' group. The subject of the morning was female highwaymen, or highwaywomen depending on your preference.
During the course of the session an article was read about several of these women. If you care to read it you can find it here. One of the sentences reads, "Alongside highway robbery, Ann Meders born in 1643, made fraud and bigamy her special interests."
That was enough for me. Out of all these women, the bored and the desperate, out of all their deeds, I couldn't leave that sentence behind. Hence the above letter. It was actually free written in the cafe as a monologue. I've altered it a little to make it a letter, but only as far as necessary. Ann Meders was hung at the age of thirty. I think my fictional autistic Ann would get into trouble too after sending that letter.
I will stress that while I have my special interests, and while special interests do get discussed sometimes in groups, I do not share the interests of Ann Meders and I haven't seen Ann's interests raised. I've seen all the others she mentions in her letters. They're real. But I haven't seen anyone plotting how to defraud their illegal husbands. I also have no good reason to claim Ann as an autistic woman or to place a seventeenth century highway robber in the position of being able to join online autism groups.
Sunday, 11 June 2017
This Transgender Woman Says, "I Am A Woman. Don't You Ever Tell Me I'm Not."
I feel sorry for my friends sometimes. Because when my head really focuses on something it REALLY focuses. Conversely when it doesn't focus it REALLY doesn't focus.
A case in point today. I was out walking today and as I sat and had lunch I got to thinking. Maybe being misgendered again by an old friend affected me more than a null amount. Maybe I'd taken in more about some transphobic abuse recently than I thought. And maybe reading this morning about the suicide of another abused transgender person made me more sad than I'd realised.
But I got to thinking. This thought.
___________________________
Thoughts that sprang up as I sat by a field today. They're quite long. Sorry about that.
There are phrases I refuse to use and really hate to hear used about me:
Clare identifies as female.
Clare identifies as a woman.
Why this refusal, when these things are of course a part of my identity?
Simple. It's because a cisgender woman would never be told they "identify" as a woman. They would just be seen as a woman. Full stop.
So no, I don't just "identify" as female, as a woman.
I AM female.
I AM a woman.
Full stop.
A woman, just like any other woman. I just happen to be a woman with a penis. But my genitals don't define me.
To insist on saying I "identify" is to place my womanhood in a different category to that of a cisgender woman. It's a belittling of my womanhood. Almost a denial. It leaves room for doubt a place for saying "Well it's all very well her identifying that way but ..." Or worse - him. Yeah, I got misgendered on Facebook only yesterday. Which stinks but in this particular case I forgive the offender.
I AM a woman. I AM female. Full stop.
Accept it. Because anything less than your acceptance of this truth is unacceptable to me.
I know most of you are fine with this. For most of you there's not a doubt in your head that I'm just as much a woman as your own mother is or was. I am safe with most of you and know that, even if we have arguments and massive disagreements, you will treat me as the woman I am.
If you don't accept this truth - that I am she, woman, female - then feel free to unfriend me because I really haven't got time or energy to waste on people who can't or won't accept such basics about me.
And if there happens to be anyone reading this who would ever dream of deliberately calling me "he" then just go. Please go. My life will be richer without you.
There are phrases I refuse to use and really hate to hear used about me:
Clare identifies as female.
Clare identifies as a woman.
Why this refusal, when these things are of course a part of my identity?
Simple. It's because a cisgender woman would never be told they "identify" as a woman. They would just be seen as a woman. Full stop.
So no, I don't just "identify" as female, as a woman.
I AM female.
I AM a woman.
Full stop.
A woman, just like any other woman. I just happen to be a woman with a penis. But my genitals don't define me.
To insist on saying I "identify" is to place my womanhood in a different category to that of a cisgender woman. It's a belittling of my womanhood. Almost a denial. It leaves room for doubt a place for saying "Well it's all very well her identifying that way but ..." Or worse - him. Yeah, I got misgendered on Facebook only yesterday. Which stinks but in this particular case I forgive the offender.
I AM a woman. I AM female. Full stop.
Accept it. Because anything less than your acceptance of this truth is unacceptable to me.
I know most of you are fine with this. For most of you there's not a doubt in your head that I'm just as much a woman as your own mother is or was. I am safe with most of you and know that, even if we have arguments and massive disagreements, you will treat me as the woman I am.
If you don't accept this truth - that I am she, woman, female - then feel free to unfriend me because I really haven't got time or energy to waste on people who can't or won't accept such basics about me.
And if there happens to be anyone reading this who would ever dream of deliberately calling me "he" then just go. Please go. My life will be richer without you.
_______________________
I posted my thought on Facebook. Responses happened. They included this one:
Like
most people, your spirit is female, your mind is male and your body...
well, you can't really argue with that can you? Well you can... You can
argue until you're blue in the face, but it doesn't really change the
world or stop poverty and homelessness
now does it? I quite often feel like a man trapped in a woman's body,
but I expect most normal women feel that way depending on their mood and
men the same. It is NORMAL!!!! Going on and on about gender just feeds
and breeds sexism and gender stereotypes. Sexism causes arguments and
repression so give it a rest eh? Right, time to do the washing up.
And that's where I start to feel sorry for my friends. Because I couldn't let it go. Not at all. My little autistic brain collided with my transgender nature. Pow. Pow. Explosions. Fire.
And this happened. The tone police may be in contact with me very soon:
________________________________________
What evidence do you have that most people's minds are male and spirits female? My mind feels pretty female to me thanks. And my body is mine. Since I'm a woman it must be a woman's body. QED. It's quite simple really. It's mine so it's a woman's. Just one that happens to have a penis attached. Which has made for a much harder life. Much, much harder.
Try to understand just how much harder it is to be transgender. And then you'll undoubtedly decide you're not in a position to tell us how it is. You'll be happy to not kick us from your social position above us.
I don't go on about gender much. I mean, you're the one who went on last weekend about how you were telling your child that I used to be a man and then quizzed me about what my name used to be (which is none of anyone's business whatsoever unless I voluntarily share that information). I didn't bring up my gender. I didn't think about sharing with your child that I'm transgender. You did. Not me.
And why the hell did you want to know my old name anyway? Why did you think that was your business? What does it matter to you?
I don't go on about it much. But it gets thrown at me:
Every time I'm treated as not a proper woman. Every time I get called he or stared and glared at or called shocking or an abomination. Every time some shit comedian makes a joke in which trans people are the joke. Every time someone wants my old name. Every time I'm misgendered to my face. Which hasn't happened to me since, oh when was it? Ah yes, it was yesterday.
Every time the person doing it tries to justify why it's okay to do it. Every time someone asks about whether I've had "the op" YET. Every time I get some dumb ass - often from the US military - sending me messages on Facebook because ooh they fancy "trannies". That time I was told I was shocking or that time a guy threatened to set me on their child because I was such a monster. Every time I'm told I'm not welcome in a space because it's for women. Every time I'm told I'm not as much of a woman as one with a vagina but the man who sexually assaulted me didn't seem to care about that did he?
Through all the days and years of fighting just to be me. Fighting to get my own gender on my own passport. And I needed a psychiatrist's letter for that. Have you ever needed psychiatrist's letters in order to convince organisations that you're a woman? I have.
And every time I hear about another abused and bullied trans person committing suicide. Which I haven't heard about since, oh when was it. Ah yes, it was today.
All we want is acceptance (never just toleration) as who and what we are. That's all. Acceptance. Full acceptance.
And we're not ever going to bow down to anyone who tells us to shut up about it and give it a rest. Not until we have that full acceptance. Not until people aren't disowned by their families for being trans. Not until people aren't bullied and abused in the street by strangers.
Not until people stop telling trans women they've got men's bodies and trans men that they've got women's bodies.
Not until we have a legal system in which we can define our own gender without it needing cash, boards of psychiatrists and supporting evidence from medical professionals.
And fuck it. And I don't in any way apologise for my language. I know that trans people being accepted isn't going to solve world homelessness. So bloody what? What the sodding hell does that have to do with it? I'll tell you. Nothing. At all. But what it will solve is the agony and pain and everything else that trans people suffer. And that's got to be worth it.
And guess what. There are plenty of people who have been chucked out of their homes for being transgender. Plenty more who have been chucked out for being gay, bi, lesbian. In fact about a quarter of young homeless people are homeless because they've been rejected.
So yeah, actually, talking about this and fighting for acceptance will solve some of the problem of homelessness. Because one day we hope to see a country in which no young person is chucked onto the streets because of sexuality and gender. Let's keep talking. Let's contribute to solving this thing.
And fuck it again. Do you really think we would have got as far as we have on this road to acceptance if people hadn't talked about it? Lots. We wouldn't. We'd still be back where we were decades ago when being trans was seen as a mental illness and when people tried their best to cure so many of us - just as they did to gay people.
We talk about it because talk changes things. It creates the better future that we want to live in.
And damn it again you. What do you mean "most normal women?" Are you in that category? Am I? Damn you if you think I'm not a "normal woman" when I'm a woman. You know what? If you believe that then feel free to unfriend me. Don't just feel free. Just do it. Please.
Because I am in no way a "woman trapped in a man's body."
I can't help what you feel. But me, I'm just a woman.
Thanks for listening.
________________________
Yes. I feel sorry for my friends sometimes.
Monday, 5 June 2017
The Jehovah's Witnesses Ask "Is The Bible Really From God?"
Warning: This post is a self-indugent trip into one of my special interests.
Yesterday I accepted the Jehovah's Witness offer of a publication. "Awake!" It asks the question, "Is the Bible Really From God?"
If you happen to want to read it you can find it here. I link to it because otherwise commenting about it as I have below would not be fair. The magazine contents do not reflect my own opinions.
I believe the article to be almost hilarious in the points it makes. They are points that really ought not to be made in any serious study of any ancient text, religious or secular.
The article begins by claiming the Bible (which incidentally says the sun was created after life on Earth) is scientifically accurate and therefore should be believed. As if it's meant to be science. The writer asks the reader to "Consider examples from the fields of meteorology and genetics." Okay, I'm game. I'll consider them. I'm absolutely shattered this afternoon and my head's not up to much more than playing with its continuing obsession with all things God!
Meteorology - Formation of Rain
The writer of the article claims that the writer of Job shows a creator who "does understand the rain cycle and saw to it that a human writer would include the facts accurately in the Bible."
It makes the claim based on Job 36:27-28. My English Standard Version renders this as
For he draws up the drops of water;
they distill his mist in rain,
which the skies pour down
and drop on mankind abundantly.
The writer of the publication claims this shows a perfect picture of evaporation, condensation, and precipitation such as we all learn in school. That could be an impressive thing to find in an ancient text although by the time Job was written, probably in the sixth century BCE, scholars were speculating and often understanding that rain originates from the water below being drawn up. How could this information be included in the Bible? It doesn't need to be some kind of prescience of science. It can just be an idea that the writer had already encountered.
It becomes even less impressive when we realise that the words commonly translated "draws up" don't mean that at all. Not at all. They actually mean "draw away". The picture here probably isn't of a properly understood water cycle at all. In reality it probably mirrors an idea that the clouds and the rain are drawn away from a great mass of water above.
So it's probably not scientifically accurate. And even if is broadly accurate it could just be reflecting a known idea.
It might also be fun to respond to the Witness that the words in the Bible were put into the mouth of Elihu, one of Job's friends. God's response to his words begins, "Who is this that darkens counsel by words without knowledge?" Or that God's response in chapter 38 mentions "the springs of the sea" - echoing that idea commonly held then and for many centuries afterwards that the water on earth was also replenished by percolation.
And yet it doesn't matter. The whole conversation is poetry not science. As poetry it's very beautiful and the imagery is stupendous. As science it stinks. It's okay that it stinks. Poetry books tend to stink as science and science books make for awful poetry.
I'd recommend reading Job. Considering the story and playing with the concepts. Delving into the images and ideas and being amazed at this ancient work of literature. I say that as someone who no longer believes in the personal God the writer inspires us to follow and trust.
Genetics - Development of the Human Embryo
It quotes a verse which my Bible reads as "Your eyes saw my unformed substance," translates it as "embryo" and tries to prove from that single verse that the psalmist was well schooled in genetics! Accurate science. The article writer admits it's poetic language but then tries to say King David, to whom the psalm is traditionally attributed, was being accurate about the human genetic code.
I think that's crazy but the Jehovah's Witness who talked to me about it yesterday until I had to rush for my bus took it totally seriously. I used to take similar things just as serious. When you're stuck in a dogmatic religion and believe it is the only way to truth and salvation then it's almost impossible to see through things like this. People can gaze on open mouthed and apply reason and you won't be able to see it. I look back at some things I used to believe and wonder how on earth I - with an IQ above 150 - ever managed to believe such unreasonable things wholeheartedly and call them reasonable.
For some reason the article writer doesn't quote the previous verse: "When I was being ... intricately woven in the depths of the earth." I'm not sure they could claim that one as being scientifically accurate. No geneticist says that we humans are woven in the depths of the earth.
It's not scientifically accurate. Of course it isn't. Again, it doesn't matter. Not one bit. Because it's poetry. And poetry written by someone living thousands of years ago with a very different view of the world and the universe than the one we have now.
Part of that poetry was very important to me when I came out as transgender. It's a part that's been important to many LGBT christians. Verse 14 is a wonderful thing to hold onto when you've been hurt by churches for being who you are.
I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made.
Wonderful are your works;
My soul knows it very well.
It was very reassuring to me at the time. I'm transgender. God made me this way. And that's just as wonderful as if he/she/they had made me cisgender. I held that verse close to my heart and mind and wrote about it too.
Less important to me though were later verses in the psalm:
Oh that you would slay the wicked, O God!
O men of blood depart from me!
They speak against you with malicious intent:
your enemies take your name in vain.
Do I not hate those who hate you, O Lord?
And do I not loathe those who rise up against you?
I hate them with complete hatred;
I count them as my enemies.
Those verses are rarely quoted. They're not in hymns. When the psalm was read in my old church (Metropolitan Community Church) we missed those verses out. They are persona non grata. We don't follow those ones. It's just as well we don't or we might set out to be like King David and conquer and kill all the neighbouring nations who don't follow our God. It was a different time. If we raised up those verses we'd quickly become a Christian version of ISIS - who raise up such verses from the Qu'ran.
Those hate verses are followed by a final verse. We read that one. Everyone does. It's in hymns and choruses. We like it.
Those hate verses are followed by a final verse. We read that one. Everyone does. It's in hymns and choruses. We like it.
Search me, O God, and know my heart!
Try me and know my thoughts!
And see if there be any grievous way in me,
And lead me in the way everlasting.
Nowadays of course we'd say "Yes, there's a grievous way in you David. You hate people with a different religion to you." But let's ignore that for today. Let's also ignore that the Hebrew word and idea could sometimes mean something very different to the word in English translation and usage - and that Jesus didn't really tell us to hate our parents even though our English Bibles tell us he did.
The poetry of the Psalms can be amazing. With or without faith it's an amazing body of literature. Yes, it's got those hate verses but every single ancient work has things that we would now refuse to make a part of our life. Ancient writers, the wisest of their day, say cultural things we would now reject. That's okay. They are from another culture and age and there's no need to rip up the books.
The mistake made in this Jehovah's Witness publication - as in many conservative Christian or Bible-based publications - is to attempt to turn an ancient book of faith into something that it was never meant to be: Science.
In doing so they've turned something that's often stunningly beautiful into something that deserves only to be laughed at, ridiculed and rejected. Yes, they turn their God into a laughing stock.
In doing so they've turned something that's often stunningly beautiful into something that deserves only to be laughed at, ridiculed and rejected. Yes, they turn their God into a laughing stock.
I'm going to stop at that point. I'm not going to examine the article's claim that the Bible accurately predicts the future. I'm not going to examine the claim that the Bible answers life's big questions. It does. That's a given. The scriptures of all religions answer life's big questions. They just disagree in places on what the answer is.
I'm also not going to answer the question that's been on your lips for your entire life. "The Sea Otter's Fur: Was It Designed?" The magazine doesn't answer the question either. Disappointing!
You've probably been very bored reading what I've just written. I had fun with it. That's the nature of my obsession, my special interest.
My sadness is that some people will encounter the ludicrous scientific claims about meteorology and genetics, be amazed by them, and be one step along the way to becoming a Jehovah's Witness. A group that wouldn't agree with what I said about LGBT Christians. Not in the slightest. A group that is monolithic, dogmatic and exclusivist. Much as they smile at me in the street as they hold out their publications I would not be safe in their midst. Not for long. A 2014 survey showed that the Jehovah's Witnesses are the most homophobic of all major religious groups in the USA. The best article I've found about it online is this one, simply because it quotes so many primary sources. They've told me in the street that I'm fine, that I'd be welcome, that God loves me, that I'd be safe there. It's a lie. Their own writings demonstrate it to be so.
My gladness is that the Jehovah's Witnesses were not the only people offering something on the street of central Newcastle yesterday. I took the plunge and joined a group with an offering that condemned nobody, welcomed everyone, and truly spread some love totally free from dogma and judgement.
We offered hugs. Free hugs. And for those who didn't want a hug a smile or a kind word.
Someone tried to offer me money. Because they found it hard to believe people would just stand there offering something and expecting nothing, preaching nothing, embracing everyone.
My gladness is that the Jehovah's Witnesses were not the only people offering something on the street of central Newcastle yesterday. I took the plunge and joined a group with an offering that condemned nobody, welcomed everyone, and truly spread some love totally free from dogma and judgement.
We offered hugs. Free hugs. And for those who didn't want a hug a smile or a kind word.
Someone tried to offer me money. Because they found it hard to believe people would just stand there offering something and expecting nothing, preaching nothing, embracing everyone.
That's what we did and it was an excellent time. I say that as someone, autistic, who happens to have problems hugging people. I'm usually a non-hugger. But I went out hugging and it brought smiles to people and reassurance to people too the day after another terrorist attack.
I still have hug issues. But I'd join those people and give out free hugs again in an instant. It was like a perfect expression of love. A piece of Biblical excellence because "perfect love casts out all fear." Others gave a perfect expression later in the day. I rushed for my bus to get to a community festival. 500 people attended and received something beautiful in the west end of Newcastle. This time I was on the receiving end.
It was a fabulous day. I saw lots of saints. They might have a religious faith. They might not. It doesn't matter. To me they are saints.
Saturday, 3 June 2017
Remembering The Day My Pastor Called Me An Abomination
This weekend it is four years since I first addressed myself without guilt as Clare. It's my re-birthday tomorrow.
Just been thinking of my experiences in a church that meets in a city centre location in Newcastle.**
They were decidedly unpleasant and the things said to me in a three hour private talk with the pastor were nothing short of disgusting - that I'm an abomination, that there's no way at all I could possibly have been a Christian unless I at least want to repent of being transgender. He said lots more too.
I remembered this because of a discussion elsewhere in which Jewish tradition was mentioned positively. I referred to Jewish tradition and teaching in my talk with that pastor. He said "Well the Jews will say anything won't they" and told me not to refer to Jewish tradition or teaching because, after all, they rejected Jesus.
I was shocked by so much of what was said. I guess I was a bit stupid to be shocked because these attitudes aren't uncommon in conservative Christian circles.
I was wounded too. So wounded that I went home and wrote a poem about it. It became one of my first blog posts. Here it is. Under this link.
I was also saddened. The church that planted the one in the city centre location** states on their website that God does not discriminate over matters of sexuality or gender. It turned out that their version of God very much does discriminate.
Had things been different I might have acted too. If I'd known how.
Should I have alerted the people who run the city centre location** that I had been treated so appallingly by an organisation they hire their premises to?
Perhaps. Perhaps I should have made waves - just as, had I known how and had the mental health for it, I should have made a police complaint against the city centre gym that told me I wouldn't be allowed to change in the changing room and would have to use a toilet cubicle.
Perhaps I should complain more. Not for my sake. But for the sake of other transgender people. Another transgender person might be crushed by that church. And we all know that transphobic abuse leads in some cases to suicide.
Three and a half years have passed since that day. I haven't been back to the church. I've seen that man again. Been in the same room as him. But I haven't spoken to him.
Maybe I should. The next time I see him. Tell him I forgive him. He's a bigot. He doesn't know it but he is. An interpretation of a religious text does not exempt anyone from bigotry - it didn't exempt me either when I followed similar interpretations of the same book. He's a transphobic man who treats people like me like shit. I worry for any transgender person who ever comes into contact with the church he runs or, heaven forbid, is forced to grow up there full of enforced self hatred.
And yet ... he would tell me he was only speaking to me out of love for me. That's almost more sad than the words he spoke to me.
And yet ... he would tell me he was only speaking to me out of love for me. That's almost more sad than the words he spoke to me.
The church still meets in that room.
Unless things have changed, a blatantly transphobic organisation - with a touch of anti-semitism - still meets in that city centre location**.
Perhaps even now, after all this time, I should mention it to them.
Perhaps.
**I originally stated where the city centre location was. I've removed this information. I realise that, since I don't have proof of what was said to me, it's possible that I'd be sued at some time in the future. I don't want to leave myself open to that possibility.
Monday, 29 May 2017
I Was Baptised By Poseidon And It Was Wonderful Even Though He's Not Real
I admit it. I'm into some shit that people would rightly call weird. They'd say I'm off my head and have lost all sense of reason.
In the last week I've taken the strangeness to a new level. A week ago today I was walking in the Derwent valley. Taking a rest at the top of a hill - I'm not the fittest of individuals - I looked at the trees and was surprised to spot a wolf sitting in the branches. Who wouldn't be surprised at this turn of events? Since wolves aren't known for sitting in the branches high in trees. And they're also not known for living in the Derwent valley or indeed anywhere else in the country. Imagine the effect on my surprise when the wolf turned towards me, transformed into some kind of wild cat, and smiled at me for a while before wandering away through the branches of the trees.
I sat and pondered this for a while. Then the branches shimmered and I saw in them the god Poseidon. Yes. Him. The actual ancient sea god. In a wood. Not in the sea. He stood there, complete with trident and crown and I accepted this turn of events. I'd run out of space for surprise. He looked at me for a while and then spoke, simply saying "Come, receive my gift." I was disappointed because I didn't know how to come to him to receive a gift. After a while he nodded at me and shimmered away.
I told a new friend this. Explained how I'd encountered Poseidon. Even though, quite obviously, he doesn't actually exist. She said, "But he does exist. I talk to him all the time." Sometimes it's good to share things with people who turn out to be pleased you've found some sanity rather than wanting to reach for a new anti-psychotic medication to alleviate the hallucinations you keep having.
Two days ago I visited the sea. I found a wonderful spot. The tide was at its lowest point and many rocks were uncovered. Lots of amazing rock pools. Lots of space. And no people. I spent over an hour there before I had to leave to be somewhere else. I'd have loved to stay longer and will return. Well, nearly no people. Two guys sat nearly 100 metres away near the cliff. And at one point a guy with a towel wandered close before wandering off again. To be honest I was hoping he would be someone so in tune with the needs of everyone that he was only there to give me a towel. Unfortunately I remained towel-less and he towel-ful.
I sat close to the water. As close as I could without being sprayed. And I meditated for a while. Opening my eyes I saw Poseidon again. This seemed more normal. While it may be abnormal to encounter a non-existent ancient god in person at least he was in the right place this time. He spoke to me again. We talked for a while and I cried out to Spirit in acceptance of life.
After a while things got physical. I had to respond in action. He said that he didn't want me to do this where the sea met the rocks because that would have been too dangerous. But he pointed me to a rock pool behind where I sat. A very deep rock pool full of life and the most perfect shade of blue-green you can imagine. He told me to go and dip my hands and wrists into the water and feel its life.
I knelt by that pool, obedient. Felt the water. It was cold! But brilliant and had I the right clothes and a towel it would, later, have been tempting to immerse myself in the pool. Poseidon spoke again. He told me to lean further out and pour the sea water over my head, to baptise myself into a new sense of Spirit. He gave me the words to say. I won't repeat them here. Partly because they were for me and for that occasion. Partly because many of them are lost. I haven't been told to write a liturgy for others or to start a Poseidon Spirit cult. Not yet anyway!
So with his help I baptised myself.
I then returned to the sea and stood on the one rock higher than the rest and watched the sea strike the shore below me. I shouted into the sea. I sang. I prayed - mostly in Christian language because that's the language I have even though I don't have the doctrine to go with it. When I call out "Come Holy Spirit" I'm in no way calling to the third person of a Trinitarian God who is what the Christians claim. And yet the words are working for me. If I say "Lord" or "God" or any of the other words or even "Baptism" I'm not saying them as you might find them in the Catholic Catechism.
Then Poseidon said to head to another pool. Baptise myself in that one too. And we sat together. We might have shared a pot of tea had we had a pot to share.
Reluctantly I had to leave for an event. I didn't want to. I wanted to stay with the god. With the rocks and the sea and watch as the tide continued to rise. Feel the breeze. Feel the sunlight. Soak myself some more. Meditate in that place of near total solitude. Explore the rock pools. Watch the seaweed forests rise up again. But I had to leave.
I had a good time at that event. A social occasion. The new friend I mentioned was there and she was so pleased that I'd met Poseidon again. There was talking. A guided meditation based in part on opening up channels between chakras. And we each drew cards from an animal tarot pack. I drew the monkey and the raven.
So what do I say now about all this?
1. I'm not going to call it weird any more. I'm going to own it as my experience and say it is what it is. Nobody else has to believe a word of it. You can call it weird. Call it whatever you like. But I did meet Poseidon. In some way or other. Even if he isn't real. Even if he is just a symbol, a story. Stories are immensely powerful. I met a philosopher a while ago who argued that stories are powerless and we should give them up for pure reason. He was wrong. That's my dogmatic statement for today. He was wrong.
Perhaps when we tell the most powerful of stories they are real in that moment. Perhaps I need to express what I might mean by real before I write a sentence like that.
2. I love tarot cards. I'd love to have more of them and to give myself the time to use them, to learn more about them. Many of the sets contain seventy-eight works of art. The imagery is wonderful and the stories and interpretations are fascinating.
I don't believe that tarot or other ways of divination have any power in themselves whatsoever. Whatever interpretation a book may give to the card drawn is of no use. Except that we then, from our own wisdom and inner intuitive knowledge, bring power to it and learn what we may learn. Or we bring our own ego and arrogance or shame to it and replace the truths with lies. It can be hard to know the difference.
Still, I did enjoy drawing the monkey and then the raven. Especially the raven. It's kind of my animal. Also the animal of the new friend as it happens. And in claiming that I have new ways in which to look into my life and being and hopefully learn something. It was interesting too at a writing workshop based on tarot this year to draw the devil followed by three sixes from the minor arcana. The Devil. 666. That was amusing.
3. I don't believe Poseidon is real. I don't believe any of the gods are real. Not the god of the Christians, the many gods of the Hindus, and not the gods of the many religions that have passed into history. My new friend says our belief brings them their existence. Maybe that's so in a way. The Hindus sometimes say they have a thousand gods, none of whom are divine. I like that idea. Pray to a god and the god is not reality. The god is a powerful symbol though. A personalised emanation. A holder of a facet of reality.
Poseidon spoke to me. That's a powerful thing. Even though he's not real. Speaking to unreal gods is powerful. I was talking with a Discordian a while ago who said to me how it was amazing that many changes come from praying to a god he knows full well doesn't exist. I presume he spoke of Eris. Maybe it will be the same for me.
4. I want to dig more deeply into all the things I will still habitually call weird. I have friends who tell me how much tapping (EFT) helps them. EFT is nonsense - but I'll try it one day. I want to enter into considering the Sephiroth, run more into meditation, and learn of a whole load of different ways. I want to explore energy work more. I learned to balance chakras and auras as a teenager and I want to return to it and I don't give a damn whether or not science would ever tell me they're real things or whether they're just superb symbols that can be used for understanding, healing and realisation of truths and ideas. I want more of the woo. More of the nonsense.
5. I say that while wishing to remain completely skeptical. To keep my brain screwed in place and to call out fake therapies. It's all well and good using the stories, the symbols, the cards and the gods to understand and grow. But when they're marketed erroneously as curers of disease or packaged as the truth in themselves then everything changes and something that may be good becomes something that is intensely bad.
6. I want to say it again. Because I believe it. Poseidon talked with me and led me through a baptism in sea water. Even though he's not real.
And so I will return to the sea. Perhaps Poseidon will be there again. Perhaps not. Perhaps I will only (only!) encounter the universe, nature, the surface of the deepest water. That will be enough. What more is needed? Ancient gods are just an added bonus in the expression of life.
I began writing this text with a very different plan in mind. I was going to speak out against woo. Against all the rubbish people speak and sell and how dangerous some of it actually is. Instead I've written something that most people would say is also woo, rubbish, nonsense.
They're right. It is. Because quite clearly I've been communing with a nonexistent deity. It's nonsense. You're right. I could have been hallucinating accidentally. Then more purposefully. I understand that hallucinations are more common among autistic people and I've certainly hallucinated before in more scary, sometimes terrifying, ways.
And yet it isn't nonsense or just my head playing a trick. Because as a symbol, as a path into understanding, Poseidon has been very powerful for me in the last week. I call upon no one to believe in him. He's not real. I don't believe in him. He's not real. And yet I spoke with him and would happily do so again and I am happy to find meaning in the experience.
Hail Poseidon! (Unreal) God of the Sea! May I find whatever wisdom I need to draw from your story and from the waters you (don't) rule.
Hail Poseidon!
In the last week I've taken the strangeness to a new level. A week ago today I was walking in the Derwent valley. Taking a rest at the top of a hill - I'm not the fittest of individuals - I looked at the trees and was surprised to spot a wolf sitting in the branches. Who wouldn't be surprised at this turn of events? Since wolves aren't known for sitting in the branches high in trees. And they're also not known for living in the Derwent valley or indeed anywhere else in the country. Imagine the effect on my surprise when the wolf turned towards me, transformed into some kind of wild cat, and smiled at me for a while before wandering away through the branches of the trees.
I sat and pondered this for a while. Then the branches shimmered and I saw in them the god Poseidon. Yes. Him. The actual ancient sea god. In a wood. Not in the sea. He stood there, complete with trident and crown and I accepted this turn of events. I'd run out of space for surprise. He looked at me for a while and then spoke, simply saying "Come, receive my gift." I was disappointed because I didn't know how to come to him to receive a gift. After a while he nodded at me and shimmered away.
I told a new friend this. Explained how I'd encountered Poseidon. Even though, quite obviously, he doesn't actually exist. She said, "But he does exist. I talk to him all the time." Sometimes it's good to share things with people who turn out to be pleased you've found some sanity rather than wanting to reach for a new anti-psychotic medication to alleviate the hallucinations you keep having.
Two days ago I visited the sea. I found a wonderful spot. The tide was at its lowest point and many rocks were uncovered. Lots of amazing rock pools. Lots of space. And no people. I spent over an hour there before I had to leave to be somewhere else. I'd have loved to stay longer and will return. Well, nearly no people. Two guys sat nearly 100 metres away near the cliff. And at one point a guy with a towel wandered close before wandering off again. To be honest I was hoping he would be someone so in tune with the needs of everyone that he was only there to give me a towel. Unfortunately I remained towel-less and he towel-ful.
I sat close to the water. As close as I could without being sprayed. And I meditated for a while. Opening my eyes I saw Poseidon again. This seemed more normal. While it may be abnormal to encounter a non-existent ancient god in person at least he was in the right place this time. He spoke to me again. We talked for a while and I cried out to Spirit in acceptance of life.
![]() |
Image taken from here. |
After a while things got physical. I had to respond in action. He said that he didn't want me to do this where the sea met the rocks because that would have been too dangerous. But he pointed me to a rock pool behind where I sat. A very deep rock pool full of life and the most perfect shade of blue-green you can imagine. He told me to go and dip my hands and wrists into the water and feel its life.
I knelt by that pool, obedient. Felt the water. It was cold! But brilliant and had I the right clothes and a towel it would, later, have been tempting to immerse myself in the pool. Poseidon spoke again. He told me to lean further out and pour the sea water over my head, to baptise myself into a new sense of Spirit. He gave me the words to say. I won't repeat them here. Partly because they were for me and for that occasion. Partly because many of them are lost. I haven't been told to write a liturgy for others or to start a Poseidon Spirit cult. Not yet anyway!
So with his help I baptised myself.
I then returned to the sea and stood on the one rock higher than the rest and watched the sea strike the shore below me. I shouted into the sea. I sang. I prayed - mostly in Christian language because that's the language I have even though I don't have the doctrine to go with it. When I call out "Come Holy Spirit" I'm in no way calling to the third person of a Trinitarian God who is what the Christians claim. And yet the words are working for me. If I say "Lord" or "God" or any of the other words or even "Baptism" I'm not saying them as you might find them in the Catholic Catechism.
Then Poseidon said to head to another pool. Baptise myself in that one too. And we sat together. We might have shared a pot of tea had we had a pot to share.
Reluctantly I had to leave for an event. I didn't want to. I wanted to stay with the god. With the rocks and the sea and watch as the tide continued to rise. Feel the breeze. Feel the sunlight. Soak myself some more. Meditate in that place of near total solitude. Explore the rock pools. Watch the seaweed forests rise up again. But I had to leave.
I had a good time at that event. A social occasion. The new friend I mentioned was there and she was so pleased that I'd met Poseidon again. There was talking. A guided meditation based in part on opening up channels between chakras. And we each drew cards from an animal tarot pack. I drew the monkey and the raven.
So what do I say now about all this?
1. I'm not going to call it weird any more. I'm going to own it as my experience and say it is what it is. Nobody else has to believe a word of it. You can call it weird. Call it whatever you like. But I did meet Poseidon. In some way or other. Even if he isn't real. Even if he is just a symbol, a story. Stories are immensely powerful. I met a philosopher a while ago who argued that stories are powerless and we should give them up for pure reason. He was wrong. That's my dogmatic statement for today. He was wrong.
Perhaps when we tell the most powerful of stories they are real in that moment. Perhaps I need to express what I might mean by real before I write a sentence like that.
2. I love tarot cards. I'd love to have more of them and to give myself the time to use them, to learn more about them. Many of the sets contain seventy-eight works of art. The imagery is wonderful and the stories and interpretations are fascinating.
I don't believe that tarot or other ways of divination have any power in themselves whatsoever. Whatever interpretation a book may give to the card drawn is of no use. Except that we then, from our own wisdom and inner intuitive knowledge, bring power to it and learn what we may learn. Or we bring our own ego and arrogance or shame to it and replace the truths with lies. It can be hard to know the difference.
Still, I did enjoy drawing the monkey and then the raven. Especially the raven. It's kind of my animal. Also the animal of the new friend as it happens. And in claiming that I have new ways in which to look into my life and being and hopefully learn something. It was interesting too at a writing workshop based on tarot this year to draw the devil followed by three sixes from the minor arcana. The Devil. 666. That was amusing.
3. I don't believe Poseidon is real. I don't believe any of the gods are real. Not the god of the Christians, the many gods of the Hindus, and not the gods of the many religions that have passed into history. My new friend says our belief brings them their existence. Maybe that's so in a way. The Hindus sometimes say they have a thousand gods, none of whom are divine. I like that idea. Pray to a god and the god is not reality. The god is a powerful symbol though. A personalised emanation. A holder of a facet of reality.
Poseidon spoke to me. That's a powerful thing. Even though he's not real. Speaking to unreal gods is powerful. I was talking with a Discordian a while ago who said to me how it was amazing that many changes come from praying to a god he knows full well doesn't exist. I presume he spoke of Eris. Maybe it will be the same for me.
4. I want to dig more deeply into all the things I will still habitually call weird. I have friends who tell me how much tapping (EFT) helps them. EFT is nonsense - but I'll try it one day. I want to enter into considering the Sephiroth, run more into meditation, and learn of a whole load of different ways. I want to explore energy work more. I learned to balance chakras and auras as a teenager and I want to return to it and I don't give a damn whether or not science would ever tell me they're real things or whether they're just superb symbols that can be used for understanding, healing and realisation of truths and ideas. I want more of the woo. More of the nonsense.
5. I say that while wishing to remain completely skeptical. To keep my brain screwed in place and to call out fake therapies. It's all well and good using the stories, the symbols, the cards and the gods to understand and grow. But when they're marketed erroneously as curers of disease or packaged as the truth in themselves then everything changes and something that may be good becomes something that is intensely bad.
6. I want to say it again. Because I believe it. Poseidon talked with me and led me through a baptism in sea water. Even though he's not real.
And so I will return to the sea. Perhaps Poseidon will be there again. Perhaps not. Perhaps I will only (only!) encounter the universe, nature, the surface of the deepest water. That will be enough. What more is needed? Ancient gods are just an added bonus in the expression of life.
I began writing this text with a very different plan in mind. I was going to speak out against woo. Against all the rubbish people speak and sell and how dangerous some of it actually is. Instead I've written something that most people would say is also woo, rubbish, nonsense.
They're right. It is. Because quite clearly I've been communing with a nonexistent deity. It's nonsense. You're right. I could have been hallucinating accidentally. Then more purposefully. I understand that hallucinations are more common among autistic people and I've certainly hallucinated before in more scary, sometimes terrifying, ways.
And yet it isn't nonsense or just my head playing a trick. Because as a symbol, as a path into understanding, Poseidon has been very powerful for me in the last week. I call upon no one to believe in him. He's not real. I don't believe in him. He's not real. And yet I spoke with him and would happily do so again and I am happy to find meaning in the experience.
Hail Poseidon! (Unreal) God of the Sea! May I find whatever wisdom I need to draw from your story and from the waters you (don't) rule.
Hail Poseidon!
Thursday, 25 May 2017
My Transgender Coming Out Story - A Tale of Difficulties and Deep Joy
So this is me. Or one version of me. A selfie taken a few days ago in a moment of deep joy and contentment at the top of a hill not too many miles from home. I share it because it's where my story is right now, four years after coming out as a transgender woman. There I am. Just me. In what is one of the stranger pictures. You won't see many selfies of a transgender woman in a post about being transgender that look quite like this one. Welcome to my reality. I like it. Especially when I'm being a little more crazy or weird than usual.
I just read an article about what one
person has learned coming out as a non-binary trans person at the age
of 43. After 100 days they say they did everything too fast. Their
experiences are those of one person. It is their truth.
My experiences and truth are also those of one person. They're bound to be a
little different because I'm a woman, pure and simple, and about as
far from non-binary as any woman gets. The article got me thinking
about my own transgender life and the way I came out to the world and began to live publicly as a woman.
Here's a little of my experience.
Just one woman trying to navigate her way into her truth. I've free written what follows and haven't edited at all. Any mistakes are my own.
I came out to myself in a way I
couldn't ever deny again at the age of 43. 43 years to get to that point. From
then on things moved quickly.
2 weeks on: I dressed solely in women's
clothes. Except when preaching. Not publicly in skirts and dresses.
Not yet. But solely in woman's clothes I'd bought for myself via the
miracle of very cheap charity shops. I didn't have a clue what I was
doing. Everything was a matter of experimentation and sometimes I
got it very wrong and nobody told me quickly enough before I had a
chance to inflict my lack of dress sense on the world.
4 weeks on: I had told pretty much
everyone that I was now Clare. The church leaders panicked about how
to tell everyone and that delayed legal changes and the whole
process. Most people were okay about it. Some people rejected me.
Some people told me at length how staggeringly wonderful they were to
not totally reject me. Gee, thanks!
8 weeks on: Having sorted things out
with the church and had a ten day holiday as Clare (during which time
my transition was officially announced to the congregation) I got
round to legally changing my name. Much paperwork. Some people
change their name quite often. They must love paperwork.
I was that (appearing to the world) 40
something man in a frock. Dark shadows of stubble. No make up. No
hair removal. Hair that I'd cut short a few weeks before coming out.
Totally, completely obvious. I was yet to meet anyone from Tyne Trans
(as was). I had asked the GP to refer me to the gender dysphoria
service – 27 days after coming out to myself, half of which was
waiting for the appointment! - but my first appointment wasn't until
three and a half months after signing that deed poll. To all intents
and purposes anyone who saw me in the street would have clocked me as
a cross dressing man not as a woman determined to be herself.
And sometimes, unsurprisingly, the
world made things bloody difficult. Bloody difficult. Transphobia is
real. If I had phoned the police every time I experienced it I would
have been phoning a lot. Every. Single. Day. At times it was
horrible. Truly horrible. And I was one of the more fortunate
ones. Others have suffered a hell of a lot more than me after coming
out. Every one of them is amazing for getting through that hell.
When people quote the suicide and attempted suicide rate for
transgender people I can only wonder why it isn't higher. For the
record, in the UK nearly half of all transgender people have
attempted suicide.
Four years have passed since I came out
and demanded to be called Clare and she. Woe to anyone who
deliberately calls me he or protests that they don't see an issue
with it if I get misgendered or who tells me it's too hard to
remember that I'm female and so would like to be addressed as female.
Fortunately that doesn't happen much now – and most people I see
never knew me as he. Yes, pretty much my entire life, excepting
family, is filled with people I didn't know four years ago.
I've learned a lot in those four years.
Would I do it again? Come out like
that?
You bet I would. Except I'd have done
it quicker.
And I wouldn't allow a religion to
delay anything. I truly wish I'd come out to the church in the middle
of a sermon I preached. It was very tempting indeed and I wish I'd
done it. After coming out I was told that it would be "inappropriate"
for me to preach or lead anything in case "anyone is ever
worried." All the confusion. All the having to meet with
diocesan pastoral advisors and so on. Just so I could be banned and
yet find that the congregation itself was supportive. Yeah, I wish I
hadn't let the panicking of the CofE delay me for one second.
If I knew now what I knew then I
wouldn't have been so afraid. And to be honest I spent the entirety
of those 8 weeks in a state in which my great joy at accepting myself
was mixed with an immense amount of terror. Some days I didn't know
whether I could do it and without my immediate family and the support
of another church - Northern Lights MCC - I might have taken longer
about the whole thing.
If I knew now, there would have been
less fear. And I would have reached that deed poll milestone
quicker.
I have regrets. I shouldn't. Because
what's the point? I might as well regret not coming out when I was
at college – and I was thinking only this morning of a couple of
times the truth was very close to the surface in my mind and how
things could have been different if I'd only chosen to speak one
sentence differently. I might as well regret my A level choices or
giving up the violin when I was nine or anything else that I can't
change. Maybe they're not regrets. And each one led in some way to
my life being as it is.
But I'd certainly change some parts of
the coming out process if I had the chance. Not just the CofE thing.
I regret not telling my online world en
masse rather than having to pluck up courage - through terror, always
through terror - to tell people one at a time. I'm grateful my mum
accidentally outed me to some people, after which I just said "To
hell with it" and told the rest.
I regret that my Facebook account is
not the one I had under my old name. There were many years of history
on that old account and I wish I'd kept it back than and closed this
one. The account is still there. With no friends. My old name
isn't even friends with my new name.
I regret how defensive I've been about
the whole trans thing and how much of that arose from fear and an
expectation, borne of 43 years of self rejection and self hatred,
that many people who reject and hate me too. I guess most people who
come out can got through an over-defensive time arising from that
same fear. Bear with us, we get over it – just don't expect us to
ever give way to prejudice. We won't.
But these regrets and others are only
little compared to the satisfaction and life-changing wonder of
coming out at all, of acceptance. It's not just that I'm happier as
Clare, more content, and so on. My life has been completely changed
in many ways that wouldn't have been possible probably had I not done
this. Or if possible, very unlikely.
I have met so many amazing people I
wouldn't have met otherwise - including many of you. I've been so
blessed. And I meet many more amazing people every time I uncover a
little more of myself – this transgender, autistic, creative,
weirdly spiritual, nature loving woman.
I've done amazing things too. In my
own way. And being Clare has allowed me to start to work through
other aspects of my life and being and slowly begin to heal and allow
myself to be me.
Without coming out I don't think I'd
have been able to accept being autistic. I don't think I'd be
exploring creativity as I am. I wouldn't have encountered Broadacre
House, wouldn't have completely transformed my faith and spiritual
life - and I don't think I'd ever have found the freedom to leave
church and start to find my own path again.
Yes. It's been bloody difficult. And
there have been lots of difficult things in the past four years.
Autism - yeah, that's been tougher than being transgender in very
many ways. I've cried. Lots. I've been rejected by some. I've been
labelled an abomination by my own church pastor (not the CofE or MCC
one). My mental health, while generally much improved, continues to
be a minefield just as it always has.
But it's been worth it.
Fabulously, profoundly, superbly worth
it.
And I look forward to my future as
Clare, as the person I'm discovering myself to be. I am excited for
my future. Excited to meet more amazing people and do more amazing
(for me) things. Excited because there always seems to be a new
surprise when you allow the surprises and give them permission to
bring change.
I'm typing all this in my bedroom.
Nearly everything in here isn't just something I didn't own before
coming out. It's something I wouldn't have considered owning at all.
Not just the obvious clothes. But soft toys, my books, the purple
Buddha on the wall, that whisk over there that doubles as a head
massager (buying it was hilarious), precious things from autism
conferences, poetry books, writing books, the meditation material on
the bed, precious items from Manchester, even a series of books
called Skulduggery Pleasant. I wouldn't have read those if I hadn't
come out. I look at this room and know that my life is almost infinitely better for coming out.
My life is very much not as I would
have expected it to be. And the changes just keep happening. There are more on the way that I know about. And there will be more surprises too.
I give thanks for Clare.
In ten days time I will give thanks
again. For it will be the fourth anniversary of the night I looked at
myself in a mirror, fully dressed as myself without guilt for the
first time in my life, and greeted myself as Clare for the first
time. Welcomed myself into the world.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)